Skin CareMakeup and Beauty

Best eye primer for mature skin | Top products for 2023

Woman wearing eye primer

Using primers as a makeup base is ideal for retaining your desired look for more hours during the day. Primers can be used straight on the skin without applying a moisturizer or right after using your favorite face cream.

Mature skin needs a lot more care and attention before and while applying full-face makeup. Primers act as fillers that smooth out fine lines and other minimal skin imperfections. Some primers might give the skin a bit of a glow while others ensure an even tone (covering redness, yellow patches, or dark circles).

How to choose the best eye primer for mature skin

Eye primers can come as:

  • Colored base
  • Clear
  • Matte finish
  • With illuminating particles
  • In gel form
  • As a stick
  • Similar to a face cream

When looking for an eye primer, keep in mind that its formula should match your skin’s type ( for example, look for gentle ingredients if your skin is sensitive). If your preferred primer comes in various shades, choose the best match for your skin tone.

Eye primers will help keep hold of the applied concealer and avoid creasing of your eyeshadow, a common issue for mature skin.

Of course, a product that is good for you may not be as good for another person. Our skin is unique and we must find the best eye primer for mature skin that suits us best.

The best eyelid and under-eye primers for mature skin

  1. diego dalla palma Eye Primer

diego dalla palma Eye Primer

This Eye Primer from Diego Dalla Palma can help even out or conceal uneven or hyperpigmented eyelids. The product is relatively easy to apply and has a soft & creamy texture. diego dalla palma Eye Primer acts as a fantastic base for eyeshadows and holds the makeup for a long.

The primer is very light in weight so that you won’t feel a burden on your eyelids. If you want to make your eye shadows intense but have pretty sensitive skin, this product will do the job; it works fine for all skin types.

  1. AmazingCosmetics Illuminate Eye Primer

AmazingCosmetics Illuminate Eye Primer

The Amazing Cosmetics Illuminate Eye Primer is impressive. This product works fine on almost all kinds of skin types, including sensitive skin. The primer smoothens the eyelid and offers good illumination even before applying anything else. 

This primer made by Amazing Cosmetics stays there for long without revealing any cracks or fine lines; this makes it suitable for everyday use. The eye primer provides more of a natural look; it’s light in weight and can be worn alone. It offers pretty good coverage and is suited both for young ladies and for older women.

  1. TONYMOLY Cat’s Purrfect Eye Contour Stick

This contour stick from TONYMOLY comes with pretty cute packaging. It’s straightforward to use or apply and simply blends in the skin leaving behind a pearlescent finish.

You can also use this contour stick under a concealer. However, you’ll find a quite strong floral scent, but that shouldn’t be a problem.

One of the best things about TONYMOLY Cat’s Purrfect Eye Contour Stick is that you won’t feel sticky after its application.

If you’re someone with dark circles, this contour stick can be great for you. It’s because of the illumination effect which this stick provides. It’ll help you effectively lighten your dark circles and still look good.

TONYMOLY Cat's Purrfect Eye Contour Stick
  1. stila Perfect & Project Eye Shadow Primer

stila Perfect & Project Eye Shadow Primer

The Stila Perfect & Project Eye Shadow Primer is another fantastic product from this brand. It helps improve the way your eye shadows look and is absolutely free from waxes. This primer is easy to apply, and after application, it dries pretty quickly and feels as if you’re not wearing anything.

Once you apply the primer and then apply the eye shadow, you’ll feel the difference. On its application, the eye shadow fits more evenly and smoothly. Also, this primer helps the eye shadow deliver a bright appearance and stay intact for a long.

  1. Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

If the dark eyelids disturb you a lot, try Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion. Using it before applying a concealer or eyeshadow will help you lighten the dark lids. You can also expect for eyeshadow to stay once you apply this primer from Urban Decay. However, this primer may not go for everyone. You need to ensure it has nothing which messes with your skin if it’s sensitive.

It’s expensive as compared to other alternatives, but the cost is justified. It nearly uses a dot every time, so it’ll last for long. Also, this primer is suited for you if you wear makeup from early morning to evening. It spreads out smoothly and makes eye shadow application easy.

  1. Elizabeth Arden Advanced Eye Fix Primer

If you need a flawless base for your lids, Elizabeth Arden Advanced Eye Fix Primer can do the job for you. This product works pretty well on oily eyelids, and even a drop of this primer prepares a beautiful base for your eye shadow.

If you look closely, this primer comes with a tint. So, you do not necessarily need an eyeshadow; applying it alone will also look pretty good.

It delivers a smooth and finished look to your eyelid. One significant advantage of this fantastic product made by Elizabeth Arden: women of all age groups can use it. This primer is also known to stay there for a long without showing signs of fine lines or crease.

Elizabeth Arden Advanced Eye Fix Primer
  1. LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Waterproof Eye Spackle Eye Shadow Primer

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Waterproof Eye Spackle Eye Shadow Primer

The products from Laura Geller never seem to disappoint, and this Waterproof Eye Spackle Eye Shadow Primer is one fine example. This primer comes with a creamy texture, which is easy to apply and blends in quite beautifully. Even if you have oily eyelids, you can reap the full benefit of this product.

The primer is one of the most loved products from Laura Geller because of its long-lasting nature. You can dance all day, sleep on it, but your eyeshadow will remain intact with this primer. The packaging is quite inconvenient to handle. You may use this primer four or max five times, and you run out of it; this item comes in a pretty low quantity.

  1. BECCA Anti Fatigue Under Eye primer

BECCA Anti Fatigue Under Eye primer

Now, this primer from BECCA is best suited for the under-eye region. Once you apply this primer on your under-eye area, applying the concealer becomes very easy.

If you have dark circles, this product can help you lighten them to a great extent. Also, it seems to deliver a moisturizing and cooling effect to the under-eye region and helps hold the makeup for a long.

This primer goes on more like a cream, which makes it easy to apply. You can also use it alone if you don’t want to wear any makeup. It’s because once applied, it brightens and hydrates the under-eye region. It’s relatively expensive, however, worth the money.

  1. MAC Prep + Prime 24 Hour Extend Eye Base

Anyone with sensitive eyes out there? Well, this product can do the job for you and prepare your eyes well for eye makeup. It blends in nicely and even has a hydrating effect; it means, if you have dry eyes, this product can help you hold the eyeshadow in place for a long time.

On the application, you won’t experience greasy or crusty eyes. The average time it can effectively hold makeup is for about 7 hours. If you’re concerned about its quantity, don’t be because you ideally need around a drop for preparing a base. So, one tube’s going to last for long.

MAC Prep + Prime 24 Hour Extend Eye Base
  1. PÜR Get A Grip Endurance Eyeshadow Primer

PÜR Get A Grip Endurance Eyeshadow Primer

This eyeshadow primer from PÜR is a great product only if you know how to apply it because it is quite thick and tacky. So, you may face problems using this to your eyelid. You have to apply it really well, spread it out on your eyelid, and then let it dry for the best results.

Ladies with oily eyelids! It would be best if you tried the Get A Grip Endurance Eyeshadow Primer. You won’t experience any creasing or fine lines even after long hours of wearing it if applied correctly.

However, it’ll be quite hard to manage the dense and tacky nature of this primer. If you’re looking for something creamy with a soft application, this is not your ideal product.

  1. Clinique Touch Base for Eyes

Clinique Touch Base for Eyes

Clinique Touch Base comes in unique packaging and is very convenient to use. You can count on this base to stay there for long. If you’re somewhere where humidity is way out of control, this base from Clinique is going to help you keep your makeup intact without fading or forming cracks.

One thing you should keep in mind is closing the compact after use. If you don’t do this, the product will dry off and won’t remain fit for use. You can use a brush to glide this base on your eyelids and experience bliss. Once applied, you can use both powder or creamy eye shadows and expect nothing but the best.

  1. Rodial Instant Filler Primer

Are there pores or wrinkles on your face which prevent you from applying makeup? Well, you should try Rodial Instant Filler Primer. It’s beneficial in filling up the wrinkles and pores and eventually blurring them. On application, you’ll find very smooth and poreless skin. 

Whatever your age, this product is going to work just fine for you. Unlike low-quality primers, the Rodial primer never peels off the skin and leaves it oily or sticky. There’s a sweet natural fragrance, which makes this product even more appealing. Try this product for long wrinkle-free makeup.

Rodial Instant Filler Primer
  1. Trish McEvoy Eye Base Essentials

Trish McEvoy Eye Base Essentials

Another highly rated and loved product in the eye primer segment is the Trish McEvoy Eye Base Essentials. It’s one of the few primers that stay all day long and offer a fantastic bright appearance. It forms a pretty smooth base and helps hide discoloration or creepiness of the skin, making it suitable for women above 40.

The Eye base is essential to help your eye shadow stay there without crease or cracks. And, the eyelid brightener seems to add to the beauty. It delivers a unique shine that makes you look more awake and energetic. Whether you have oily skin or extra dry skin, you can always rely on this product made by Trish McEvoy.

  1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Studio Perfect Primer


Now, this primer from NYX Professional Makeup is one of the most affordable options in this segment. If you think high prices mean good quality, you may be wrong in this case. 

Studio Perfect Primer seems to outperform its cost and can help your makeup stay for long. If you wear it, say early morning, you can probably expect it to remain intact in the evening.

Once you apply this one on your face, you’ll feel how smooth and makeup ready your face becomes. Even if you have dry patches on your face, it’ll work correctly and deliver a blurred view. Make sure you shake a little bit before using it, or you may get only the oil.

  1. Pretty Vulgar – Uncaged Eye Shadow Primer

Pretty Vulgar Uncaged Eye Shadow Primer

The Pretty Vulgar eye shadow primer is one of the most loved and highly rated products on our list. Uncaged Eye Shadow Primer is super light to wear; it blends pretty easily, increasing the beauty of eye shadow.

It looks very appealing, and no matter which color you apply to this primer, it will always blend perfectly.

This product will stay for long and will hold all the makeup in place. If you’re someone who wants to wear eye makeup all day long, this fantastic primer from Pretty Vulgar is a must-try. Also, it’s relatively easy to apply and won’t leave behind muggy eyes.

  1. Hourglass Veil Mineral Primer

Hourglass Veil Eye Primer is an excellent product for someone with hooded eyelids. This eye primer is convenient and helps by keeping the eye shadow in place for really long hours.

It blends in pretty smoothly and is suited for people with sensitive skin. Also, you won’t notice any fine lines or creasing even after wearing it all day.

When you apply this primer, you have to wait for like 3-4 minutes to let it bend in. Once done, you can use the eyeshadow for the best results.

Hourglass Veil Eye Primer is quite useful for oily lids, so if you have oily eyelids, go for this one!

Hourglass Veil Mineral Primer
  1. NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base

NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base

Are oily eyelids disturbing you too? If so, NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base can be one of the best possible solutions. This base is also quite for ladies with oily eyelids. It’s straightforward to apply and offers a bright appearance after application.

NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base not only looks beautiful but helps eyeshadow stay intact without cracks all day long.

This great product from NARS is ideal for people who want their eyeshadows to look bright all day without requiring touchups. But, if you’re a mature lady, this product may not be the most ideal.

  1. SmashBox Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer
  2. Guerlain Eye-Stay Primer – Smoothing & Longwear Eye Primer
  3. bareMinerals Prime Time™ Eyelid Primer
  4. SmashBox Photo Finish Shadow Primer
  5. Anastasia Beverly Hills Eye Primer
  6. ILIA Eye Primer
  7. Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer
  8. Benefit Cosmetics Stay Don’t Stray Stay-put Primer for Concealers & Eye Shadows
  9. Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer
  10. Tarte Shape Tape 12 Hour Eye Primer Stick
  11. Lancôme Aquatique Waterproof EyeColour Base-Nude
  12. Glo Skin Beauty Eye Shadow Primer – Eye Lid Primer
  13. Clarins Instant Light Eye Perfecting Base

Primers for women over 50s would be moisturizing, successfully cover skin discoloration, and fill in troublesome wrinkles.

Applying eye primer

Do you really need an eye shadow primer?

Eye primers are the best when you want to have smooth looking skin without makeup creasing and make the wrinkles around the eye area look deeper. 

Some people prefer to use alternatives to eye primers like:

  • A simple moisturizing eye cream
  • Some touches of vaseline 
  • A lip balm stick
  • Aloe Vera gel mixed with glycerine
  • A good concealer

All of these do their job in terms of moisturizing the skin and making the makeup application easier. However, these will not help mature skin for women over 50s or 60s when the desired result is the leveling off fine and deep lines around the eyes, on the eyelids, and under the eyes.

Best and worst eyeshadow primers

Where can you buy a good eye primer for aging skin

Regardless of someone’s facial type of skin, eyelid, and under the eye, primers can be found along with other beauty products like mascara, eyeshadow, foundation, and lipstick. A quick visit to your local beauty store or a high street store will take you to the primers’ shelf.

Department stores and malls have more products in their beauty-related stores, offering a wider range for various skin types and brands (from unknown ones or the usual beauty brands to premium luxury primers). 

Probably, the easiest way is to browse for any product is via online stores. Online stores are open at any time of the day, have plenty of offers and discounts, with lots of product choices. It is a great way to check the prices, the pros and cons of different brands of eye primers, and lots of real reviews from other users.

A simple click on the names of the products on our list with the best eye primers for mature skin will take you to an online store where you can check the prices, read about their ingredients and find out what other people think of them.

If you found this article useful, we would love to hear more from you, and maybe you could tell us what product you chose as your favorite eyelid and under the eye primer. You might also be interested in reading our articles Best makeup for aging skin over 50 and Best tinted moisturizers for mature skin.

Editor's choice
Balance of Nature Supplements
Best makeup brands for sensitive skin
Woman wearing eye primer
PUR Minerals vs It Cosmetics